Thursday, February 18, 2016

CBI on the UK Housing Shortage: It’s Bad for Business

The million-plus homes deficit in Britain is treated like a social issue. It is that but so much more; leading business organisations have calculated the costs.

It’s conventional wisdom that the UK’s housing shortage is harmful to families. But when people spend too much of their income on homes, or cannot move out of parents’ homes to form new households, it creates a drag on the economy as well.

So says the CBI, “the voice of business,” in its 2014 report “Housing Britain: Building new homes for growth.” According to the CBI deputy director-general, Katja Hall, “Housing is not just a social priority, it’s a key business issue. We see the impact of too few homes being built not just on the front pages of our newspapers but in the experience of our families, friends and colleagues...it also has huge implications for our future economic competitiveness. Businesses need a flexible and mobile workforce, but the high cost of moving home, and lack of decent and affordable housing, are barriers to attracting and retaining employees.”

This is a key driver for those engaged in UK land investment, working to build homes where needed. That almost always is where a local economy is growing and one or several employers want their people to live nearby.

The CBI publication points out that restrictions on land use for new development, a function of the planning permission system has “for decades…caused cyclical house price volatility - a situation that has contributed to macroeconomic instability to the detriment of households and businesses alike.” It also cites statements from Mark Carney, Governor of the Bank of England, who has said that the housing market poses the biggest risk to future financial stability.

The CBI partnered with the Centre for Economic and Business Research (CEBR) to put numbers to these claims. Findings from this and other CEBR research include:

• £4 billion per year - How much extra spending power households would have if housing and commuting costs rose at the price of inflation (the Consumer Price Index), instead of the 56 per cent rise in UK house prices since 2004. That much incremental spending would multiply itself as goods and services are purchased.

• £770 million per year - The portion of that £4 billion that would be saved simply in reduced transportation costs if people could afford to live closer to where they work. That doesn’t account for time savings, which could be substantial. Managers of property funds wisely focus their research on sites that would serve employer needs.

• £5.5 billion - Money spent on suppliers to the homebuilding industry, part of the £12.5 billion invested in land and buildings for homes built per year (based on the 140,000 homes built in 2013, which is only about 60 per cent of what needs to be built).

• 600,000 jobs - Number of people employed in a year when 140,000 homes are built. If 250,000 homes were built, it would bring this up to about one million jobs.

The goals of the CBI are aggressive. They see a doubling of new home building (to 250,000 or more per annum). The business organisation sees it necessary for a “pipeline of land” - the work of specialists engaged in planning permissions - to deliver well-designed homes for sale or rent. Also, innovative financing programmes and an increase in the skilled workforce able to build would further this objective. A simpler and more competitive tax regime, paired with a flexible planning system, are required as well.

Investors in house development understand that both obstacles and handsome returns meet the high demand for homes. What all investors need to do is to discuss their interests in home-development investments with an independent financial advisor.

Building Upward: How the British Feel About High Rise Living

The squeeze is on as the British population continues to increase. London is in a tall building boom, but not all UK residents are willing to let go of their gardens.

The UK has a bit of an identity crisis with regard to housing development. Either we should build up into the sky or out to the green fields - or both (because we cannot afford to do neither).

There are those who take the position of protecting the greenbelts. These include supporters of the Campaign to Protect Rural England, an organisation that opposes Britain’s housing planners’ proposals to develop on a large scale - up to 15,000 homes in various parts of England. Such developments are a modest effort to address the country’s growing population and urgent housing shortage. They propose instead small developments of 6 to 12 homes scattered about the villages (note: that would require 1,250 to 2,500 villages, not all conveniently located). The thinking goes the incremental, distributed approach would impose fewer burdens on infrastructure.

Elsewhere, there are urbanites who have trouble with high rises. Which to the contrary seems only logical: if the country cannot build out, it must go up. This stripe of urbanistvalues human-scaled streets, squares and parks, and mid-height buildings. But has that battle been lost? More than 236 new high rise buildings between 20 and 75 storeys have been or are being built in London. And these are short of The Shard, which at 87 storeys became Western Europe’s tallest building in 2012.

Can we come to some kind of compromise? To anyone engaged in property funds- endeavouring to achieve planning permission to build on raw land - an all-of-the-above strategy is all that is practical. The country is short of one million homes, and the 7 per cent population growth identified in Census 2011 is likely to continue on its trajectory. The population of London itself stands today at 8.6 million people, expected to grow to 10 million in 15 years and to 11 million by 2050. People have to live somewhere.

Of course, it’s well understood that foreign nationals are buying flats in these high rises as investments, rarely if ever actually living in them. But foreign inhabitants in London are hardly new: one-third of Londoners were born somewhere else. Foreign nationals from the U.S. and Asia who are living in London are quite accustomed to high-rise views and long elevator trips to the car park - and much less inclined to tending the primroses.

The traditional English ideal is to live in a detached home with a garden, and that largely remains the case. Many property investors put their cash into real assets to develop homes closer to the ground where cities in the southeast, the west, north and midlands are growing as well. Employers find that locating outside of London enables lower costs for them and their employees. This is why proposed garden cities and other such developments, on green fields as well as brown fields, make a lot of sense.

Investors will go where the money is to be made. To build traditional detached homes, they achieve planning permission to build on unused land; this typically provides a handsome return on the investment. Alternatively, investors in high rises find the higher they build or own in one of the new high rises, the more its value increases - by about 1.5 per cent per floor. At the highest levels in the best buildings, prices begin at £1.35 million (for a one-bedroom flat) and can be worth as much as £15 million. Clearly, these are not the poorly maintained council flats of the 1960s and 1970s.

There are as many ways to invest in UK land as there are types of homes, on the ground and in the air. But would-be investors should always speak with an independent financial advisor to learn which investments and risk factors fit their individual needs and strategies.

Are Newly-Built Homes in the UK More Sustainable?

Indeed they are. But whether new builds or retrofits, increasing the energy efficiency of homes is beneficial to the UK economy in all kinds of ways.

Shockwaves hit the green house building industry in the UK in July 2015 when the Treasury announced it was dumping two planning regulations intended to ensure all new homes were “zero carbon” by 2016. The rationale was that these regulations were burdensome to homebuilders, a position that has some merit given the red tape barriers often cited as contributing to the country’s critical housing shortage.

The Treasury provided some assurances to environmentalists that it would “keep energy efficiency standards under review,” according to BusinessGreen.com, a sustainable business-focused website. The Government acknowledged the benefits of increasing energy efficiency in homes in its statements.

While this elimination of mandates might slow the advance of green home building in the UK, by no means does it suggest a return to the energy-wasteful building practices of the past. Home builders and their investors - frequently those seeking capital growth land opportunities for large-scale new building – have already been doing a pretty good job of constructing what are sometimes referred to as “high performance” homes.

The past dozen or so years of homebuilding have benefited from improved materials and methods, to significant results. The Carbon Brief, a climate science and energy policy news organisation, reported in 2014 that energy use in all UK homes, new and existing, fell by 11 per cent in the decade since 2004. Acknowledging that this was partly due to a warm winter in 2011 as well as household cost cutting due to the 2008-2010 financial crisis, several components that have become standardised in new homes contribute to energy savings as well:

• More insulation, double-glazed windows and better boilers - From the Fuel Poverty Report 2014, the portion of homes in the UK that scored in the middle- to high-efficiency ratings categories went from 45 per cent in 2008 to 70 per cent in 2012. This is attributed to better insulation, energy-efficient modern windows and condensing gas boilers that are replacing older standard boilers and combi boilers.

• Better light bulbs - EU rules that banned inefficient incandescent bulbs forced a rather rapid adoption of much more efficient compact fluorescents and now ultra-efficient LEDs. An energy expert at Oxford University, Dr Brenda Boardman, says that home lighting energy use dropped by 22 per cent from 2000 to 2012 due to better light bulbs – even while home computers and other electronics have added to the load on home electricity in this same time period.

• Energy efficient appliances - Newer, energy efficient refrigerators, ovens, dishwashers and washing machines are replacing older, less efficient models, particularly since 2008.

Because the supply chain for all of these items has learned to be greener, in order to compete effectively in an energy-educated consumer market, it means that all new construction now features greener components. Those who undertake real asset investing in new home construction need not make a tortured decision between “green” and “cost-contained,” as they are one and the same. Some of it came about by mandates, but much due to the advances in technology in response to rising energy prices and concern for the environment and climate.

Investors in home building generally do so for rational reasons - to achieve a good return on investment - however building can also affect social and environmental causes as well. Homes are needed throughout the country in all price strata. But before investing it makes sense to speak with an independent financial advisor to consider the depth and breadth of investing in UK and real estate.

200 Years of Housing Policy History in the UK: We Adapt

The changes in population, construction and infrastructure technologies have certainly improved homes in the United Kingdom. But Government policy has also played a role.

While the UK is truly in a housing crisis it is not without precedent. We need to accelerate building by about 110,000 homes per year to make up for the shortfall, thought to be in total one million homes and made more urgent by a growing population. But the UK has dealt with pressing needs for housing throughout modern history and has always managed to figure out how to do it. The relative stability of British society bears testimony to our capacity for doing so.

Two organisations have recently documented this history. They are the National Housing Federation (NHF) think tank in its report, “The Politics of Housing,” which largely concentrates on the 20th century; and the NHBC Foundation, “Homes through the decades: the making of modern housing,” a look back to about 1800. NHBC Foundation, established in 2006 by the National House Building Council, largely focuses on a sustainability agenda, risk management and consumers.

The NHF report points out that the current level of housing completions has not been this low since the 1930s, with about 115,000 new homes built in 2010 (it rose a bit to 140,000 completions in 2014). It opines that one barrier to government policy not being more successful at building is that the high degree of ownership in the country - about two-thirds of dwellings are owned by their inhabitants - necessarily dampens efforts to increase supply.

Their rationale is if you own a home in a community you like, you are less inclined to encourage development nearby that will alter your community and add burdens to its infrastructure. This is among the key challenges to capital growth partners who buy UK land and seek planning permission to convert to housing.

Note that in previous periods private ownership levels were lower: It was just 10 per cent in 1914, 25 per cent in 1939, by 1971 ownership reached 50 per cent and by 2001 it reached its peak at 69 per cent. By 2011, largely due to the financial crisis of 2008, the ownership rate declined to 64 per cent. As fewer own, more people rent - and the Buy to Let programme has played a large role in meeting some of that demand.

The NHBC Foundation report traces both the types of homes and infrastructure from the Victorian era to the present, crediting reformers, planners, architects, designers, technologists and construction teams for the advances made through the decades. While investors, such as those who prefer alternative investment funds that build physical communities, and government officials probably should be added to this list, it is clear the Foundation report looks at the broad sweep of players in ensuring comfortable and resilient homes for the British.

To coalesce the analyses of these two perspectives, consider the following points. While not in strict agreement from both analyses, several themes emerge:

• Government has always played a role - Victorian mains sewers, flushing WCs and waste collection were critical to the UK’s population growth in the 19th century. This supported the private sector investments that then could build homes in more places and in different ways.

• Population growth has been a driving factor - The UK population grew from 11 million to 32 million in the 19th century, including the urban growth from 2 million to 20 million.

• Housing is closely tied to economic stability - Since the end of the First World War, Government policy has pegged social and financial stability to housing. This led to the large-scale post-war council house building programme.

• Private ownership has risen dramatically - And as it did, privately rented housing dropped from 89 per cent in 1914 to about 10 per cent in 1999 - but has risen to about 16 per cent today. The trend is considered ahistorical and tied to the above-inflation pace of home price increases.

• The quality of housing stock has markedly improved - In the rush to replace a half-million homes destroyed in the Second World War, prefabrication was developed and enabled the construction of a stunning 354,000 new homes in 1954 alone. But that came at a price in quality. Already variable quality in new privately built homes prompted the establishment of a national registration scheme for house builders in the late 1930s. Tower blocks that introduced high-rise living often proved to be social and financial failures.

• Sprawl has always been a worry - Planning principles that apply today (to some extent) were largely established in the 1947 Town and Country Planning Act, which sought to limit suburban expansion.

Today, we wrestle with questions on the inadequate supply as well as the need for sustainable housing. The private sector has proven to inventive in achieving both objectives, however the planning process is still considered unwieldy, as the question first addressed in 1947, to block suburban expansion, is still unresolved. Developers and home builders have the capital to build, but still must convince local councils that development will benefit existing communities.

Investors in housing recognize the present-day opportunity to build for the UK’s rapidly growing population. But the complexities of investing combined with the many variables of housing require that would-be investors consult an independent financial advisor before taking a position of significance.

Wednesday, January 27, 2016

Zero inflation: How does it affect land investment and the housing sector?

Deflation can sound good to consumers’ ears, but it also alters economies and investment decisions. UK deflation is new and housing investors need to pay heed.

The UK is in a stage of exceptionally low inflation - even deflation in some sectors - which any student of macroeconomics knows has its pluses and minuses. Consumers love paying lower energy bills, but some businesses suffer if they have to cut prices to attract buyers. Borrowers suffer if they are paying back on debt incurred when prices were higher.

Investors in new home building might take notice as well. For example, capital growth land opportunities provide individuals and institutions a means to participate in the high demand for housing - finding UK land that can be converted to housing (with council approvals) and establishing homes where the local economy needs them.

But with all the moving parts of the UK economy, within the context of global economic shifts (petroleum pricing among them), where to apply money and capital is a question that isn’t easily answered. These publications have offered some perspective in 2015:

FT.com - The Financial Times’ online “UK economy at a glance” provides a rundown on more than a dozen economic indicators, including both inflation (at -0.1% as of October 2015) and the housing market. The annualised house price rise that month across the country was 6.1%, but 5% when factoring out London and the South East. Relative to inflation, the paper’s economists note, “Exceptionally low inflation, driven largely by falling oil prices, supermarket price wars and the strength of sterling keeping down the costs of imports, has been a boom for household finances.” It cites the Bank of England’s prognostication that very low/zero inflation is due to “external factors” and not indicative of a looming deflationary spiral. Relative to home buying, “the value of mortgage lending also rose by the largest amount in almost seven years,” with 69,300 mortgage approvals in October 2015, perhaps due to demand that was held back earlier in the year during the lead up to the national election.

The Telegraph - The paper’s property correspondent interviewed economists on how a deflationary cycle might affect housing prices. Making distinctions between “good” and “bad” deflation, the head of JLL residential research says a bad cycle could include flat or falling house prices. The impact could be a cooling of transactions because existing homeowners won’t feel comfortable about trading up; if they do anyway, with lower proceeds from the sale of their old home their deposits will be smaller, forcing some to accept a higher loan-to-value mortgage on their new home. “Would you buy if you think prices are going to go lower?” posed the researcher. “Homeowners like buying into a rising market.” But this would require a “sustained and persistent” deflation cycle, which he says is not yet evident.

PricedOut.org.uk - This advocacy group campaigning for affordable house prices says that “nearly 3.5 million private renters are unable to afford the average house and this number will increase further if house prices continue to rise faster than wages.” Citing how the average cost of houses is seven times that of average income, it points out how rising home prices have a perverse inflationary effect: “Rising house prices hinder the ability to build enough houses because it increases the market value of land, thereby increasing costs to the developers ... attract[ing] more speculators to the housing market as ... it makes houses more expensive.” The proposed solution is to set a target of zero per cent house price inflation, levy a higher rate of capital gains tax on property (to make speculative buying less attractive), liberalising planning policies, and otherwise encourage a zero-per cent house price inflation rate.

So regardless of whether you invest in market-traded securities or alternative investments such as land, house building, antiques or commodities, there is this unusual dynamic of very low inflation and perhaps deflation to consider.

But the chief property economist at Capital Economics, the independent macroeconomic research firm, told FT.com that the shortage of homes for sale causes an “upward momentum” defined by tight competition by more buyers chasing after too-few homes. For the most part, that’s what capital growth investors look for in alternatives to securities.

No investor can be expected to understand the many interrelated factors of any economy, deflationary or inflationary. This is why third party advice from an independent financial advisor is almost always recommended.

Sunday, January 24, 2016

Will Privatization of Public Housing Ease the Housing Shortage?

Several Government changes relative to housing associations suggest they will cease to deliver homes as needed. Private investors might be the only builders.

Several significant factors in the UK housing association sector have cast doubt on whether the growing need for housing would be abated. Indeed, these factors suggest this need will not be met if trends continue.

The Government’s abdication from supporting housing associations comes at a time when private investors’ interest in house building is growing. Alternatively, from the private sector, real asset funds seek land where it can be acquired and where planning authorities will allow for building. This is where standard supply-demand dynamics play well: with high demand come higher real returns to those funds.

But at the lower end of the market, lower income families are seeing diminishing opportunities to find housing. Consider what has happened in 2015 alone:

• In October, the Office for National Statistics reclassified housing associations as non-financial public corporations. This effectively places £60 billion of privately procured housing association debt on the Government’s balance sheet. Observers speculate Chancellor George Osborne will then try to get this debt off the public books by selling it to private investors, or remove regulator burdens on housing associations that in effect enable them to become commercial property companies - setting rents as they wish. Note that Germany’s experience with privatisation (selling to large investors that included Vonovia, Fortress and Cerberus) resulted in one million fewer social dwellings and an overall increase in housing prices.

• A few months ago, Chancellor Osborne surprised many with a forced rent cut of 1% on housing associations, in contrast to the 1% increase plus inflation as they expected. Subsequently, a survey of providers by the Homes and Communities Agency found that the associations curtailed investment plans by about £1 billion for 2015, believed to be a consequence of this rent cut. This decrease is spread across more than 200 landlords, not due to a single large drop in individual plans.

• One of London’s largest housing associations - Genesis, which owns and manages 33,000 homes in the city and the South East - announced in August it would discontinue building social housing. Contributing to this, according to an article in The Guardian, were the Government’s decision in 2010 to cut funding for social homes by 60%, and welfare reforms that reduced tenants’ ability to pay rent.

To the dismay of social housing advocates, Genesis will build homes for sale and rent at full market rates. Real asset investing of this nature is considered mission creep in that the profits from market-rate building are ostensibly targeted at subsidising social-rent dwellings. But the extent to which organisations such as Genesis go into for-profit building is an unanswered question.

Without question, new homes are needed in the UK. Private investors are keen to enter real estate as an asset-growing opportunity, which it indeed is. But as the housing charity Shelter points out, the housing shortage at all price levels is affecting both the middle and lower classes equally. Buyers are favoured by such programmes as Right to Buy, Help to Buy and Starter Homes initiatives. But the experience in some European countries has been many owners lack the wherewithal to maintain the homes they own. Instead of appreciating value, large percentages of dwellings fall into disrepair and become an asset that is hard to sell.

Those keen on investing in UK land and building should consider it as any other asset class: a balance of risk and reward is uncertain. An independent financial advisor should be able to counsel the investor in how to identify manageable risk. 

WikiHouses: What Might They Do to Alleviate the UK's Housing Shortage?

At a remarkably low cost and buildable in mere days, these energy-efficient structures might help England to build more homes faster.

There is a big idea out there called WikiHouses, and it might just be one of the key solutions to the UK housing shortage. Notably, the design-build movement is rooted in England but it’s already being tested around the globe.

A WikiHouse is essentially a flat-pack-like kit that combines 3-D printing with a very democratised, open-source approach to architecture and construction. Its progenitor, Alastair Parvin of Zero Zero Architects (Hackney, London), speaks of it as the solution for the masses, a self-build method that might make housing affordable. Which, given the high cost of housing and the inadequate supply of homes, makes the method worthy of examination.

It also might make the short list of creative concepts worth investigating for individuals engaged in UK land investing. If housing delivery in a short period of time is critical, this method offers something rather extraordinary: Single-day construction of a two-bedroom, 68-square-metre wooden frame house, at a cost of about £50,000. The construction “crew” need not even be professionals, as amateurs or volunteers can do it if, in the words of Parvin, they are “IKEA-savvy.”

The Wiki design concept is open-source, meaning designs are essentially free online and open to variation provided by anyone generous enough to do so - essentially doing for simple home designs what Wikipedia did for encyclopaedic knowledge. The design program cuts building parts - much of it orientated strand board (OSB) - with a computer numerical control (CNC) machine. As this can be done locally, where a CNC exists, the materials are less expensive because there is less transport required. And this is part of the building’s sustainability story. WikiHouses can be built to high performance standards, even to qualify as “net zero energy use” Passive House requirements.

The South Yorkshire Housing Association announced in late 2015 it would build a pilot home with the method in 2016. Should the pilot project prove successful, the association said it may enable them to affordably replace homes sold under the Right to Buy programme where low-value land areas make it otherwise an economic challenge.

Investing in UK strategic land typically involves buying the land from non-builders, for example farmers or public owners. Investors then will seek a zoning change from the local planning authorities to build, although increasingly that means selling the lots to homebuilders. The WikiHouse concept would radically change the homebuilding process, but it’s not inconceivable that the speed and lower-level of investment could compel investors to test the concept. Alternatively, an individual could purchase the land to do self-build – assuming they are “IKEA-savvy.”

The Guardian considered the WikiHouse option in an article in 2014, suggesting that land availability and cost would be the biggest barriers - particularly in densely-built London. But it went on to suggest constructing these buildings on top of existing buildings, which by law may be possible. A spokesperson for Sustainable Homes, a not-for-profit consultancy, noted that post-war pre-fab buildings were similar in concept and suffered from poor energy performance. But much has changed in the 60+ years that have passed such that those concerns may be unnecessary. WikiHouse proponents emphasise how the open-source nature will provide for innovation and adaptation to different situations, climates and design interests.

Investors in housing are by nature innovative. Every site is different and every market needs different kinds of homes to meet local demand. Meanwhile, homebuyers want quality homes that can enhance their lives and build value over time. But every investor should consider all variables relative to the house-building opportunities in the UK - an independent financial advisor is the first place to go to consider the options.